FLIGHTS
WHISKEY 101 $25
MAKERS MARK \ RITTENHOUSE RYE \ COPPER DOG
BOURBON BALLER $40
ANGELS ENVY \ GARRISON BROTHERS \ WELLER RESERVE
NOO YAWK $32
FORT HAMILTON \ COPPERSEA \ KINGS COUNTY BOURBON
THE SCOTSMAN $35
BOWMORE 12 YR \ ABERFELDY 12 \ GLENDRONACH 12 YR
BLUE GRASS STATE $29
BULLEIT\ OLD FORESTER\ WILLET POT STILL
RYE FLIGHT $30
HIGH WEST DOUBLE \ JAMES PEPPER \ TEMPLETON
Premium Whiskey Tasting on Amsterdam
The Hamilton — your go-to spot on Amsterdam, NY for a memorable whiskey tasting experience. Whether you're a whiskey enthusiast or just exploring, we offer a relaxed atmosphere, curated flights, and great company.
Whiskey Tasting Amsterdam
At The Hamilton, we’re all about celebrating the art of whiskey. Nestled in the heart of Amsterdam, NY, our space is a welcoming destination for anyone who appreciates good spirits and great company.
We believe whiskey tasting should be approachable, enjoyable, and rooted in genuine connection. Here, it’s all about the experience, the atmosphere, and the people who make it memorable.
Our Signature Irish Whiskey Flight
Each of our whiskey flights is a chapter in the broader narrative of whiskey craftsmanship. If you’re exploring the bold richness of American bourbon or the smoky subtlety of aged Scotch, we’ve designed a tasting experience that hits all the right notes.
WHISKEY 101
MAKERS MARK | RITTENHOUSE RYE | COPPER DOG
Perfect for beginners, this introduction flight walks you through three uniquely American whiskey styles.
Explore the sweetness of Maker’s Mark, the peppery spice of Rittenhouse Rye, and the smooth, blended complexity of Copper Dog. Ideal for starting your whiskey journey.
BOURBON BALLER
ANGELS ENVY | GARRISON BROTHERS | WELLER RESERVE
Dive deep into the heart of bourbon with this flight designed for bold palates.
Angels Envy delivers port-finished richness, Garrison Brothers brings a Texas-sized flavor punch, and Weller Reserve completes the set with a wheaten softness reminiscent of Pappy lineage.
NOO YAWK
FORT HAMILTON | COPPERSEA | KINGS COUNTY BOURBON
A tribute to local distilling, this New York-themed flight showcases the best craft expressions from our very own state.
A must-try for those interested in small-batch, locally distilled excellence
THE SCOTSMAN
BOWMORE 12 YR | ABERFELDY 12 | GLENDRONACH 12 YR
Venture across the Atlantic with this smooth, peaty, and richly textured Scotch whiskey flight.
Ideal for fans of aged spirits with complex flavors that unfold sip by sip.
BLUE GRASS STATE
BULLEIT | OLD FORESTER | WILLET POT STILL
This Kentucky-centered lineup is for those who appreciate deep tradition and barrel-forward notes.
From high-rye Bulleit to the iconic shape and taste of Willet, this flight is a crash course in Bluegrass
RYE FLIGHT
HIGH WEST DOUBLE | JAMES PEPPER | TEMPLETON
Bold, spicy, and endlessly interesting. Our rye whiskey flight caters to those who love a sharp edge with a smooth finish.
Perfect for winter nights or adventurous spirits.
What to Expect from a Whiskey Tasting at The Hamilton
What to Expect from a Whiskey Tasting at The Hamilton
Our tasting sessions on Amsterdam are more than just a sip-and-go. Here’s what you can expect when you reserve a tasting experience with us:
Engage Your Senses
Smell the spirit before you sip — notice the complexity, the oak, the spice, the fruit. Each pour is introduced with tasting notes and background on the distillery.
Learn the Craft
Our knowledgeable staff share fascinating insights on each brand’s history, distillation techniques, and regional distinctions. It’s not just about drinking whiskey — it’s about understanding it.
Taste with Intention
Sip, swirl, savor. Whether neat, with a splash of water, or over a large cube, we encourage every guest to find their preferred method of enjoyment.
Pairing Opportunities
Pair your taste with one of our gourmet small plates — cheeses, smoked meats, and seasonal bites crafted to enhance each flight.
Unforgettable Events & Whiskey Tastings
Who Is This For?
At The Hamilton, we welcome everyone from complete beginners to aficionados with a prized bottle collection at home.
The Whiskey Newbie
Maybe you’ve had a few good pours at bars but never really knew what you liked. A whiskey flight is a fantastic way to explore different types in a guided, pressure-free setting.
The Curious Couple
Looking for a unique date night idea on Amsterdam, NY? Nothing says romance like sipping on smooth whiskey under soft lighting with shared small plates.
The Corporate Group
We can host private group whiskey tastings that make for memorable networking or client entertainment.
The Collector
We can host private group whiskey tastings that make for memorable networking or client entertainment.
Make a Reservation
Ready to taste the difference? Whether you want to casually explore whiskey with friends or celebrate with a full flight and food pairing, The Hamilton is your destination for the best whiskey tasting Amsterdam has to offer.
AMERICAN WHISKEY BAR
998 AMSTERDAM AVE, NYC, 10025
OPENING HOURS:
MONDAY: 4PM - 2AM
TUESDAY: 4PM - 2AM
WEDNESDAY: 4PM - 2AM
THURSDAY: 4PM - 4AM
FRIDAY: 4PM - 4AM
SATURDAY: 4PM - 4AM
SUNDAY: 4PM - 12AM
Follow us on instagram@thehamiltonuws
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Yes, we can tailor your whiskey flight based on your palate. Just let our staff know if you prefer something sweeter, smokier, or spicier, and we’ll curate accordingly.
-
We do offer an Irish whiskey flight on select tasting menus and seasonal offerings. Ask our staff about availability or upcoming Irish whiskey events.
-
Most tasting experiences at The Hamilton last about 60–90 minutes, depending on your pace, the flight size, and whether you include food pairings.
-
Absolutely! We offer private group tastings perfect for birthdays, bachelor parties, corporate events, or special gatherings. Contact us for custom packages.
-
Each flight includes three curated pours, tasting notes, and insights into the distillery and production style. Some also include regional or thematic elements like bourbon, rye, or Irish whiskey flight variations.
-
Yes, we offer a small selection of non-alcoholic beverages and mocktails for guests not participating in the tasting.
-
Food pairings are optional and can be added for an extra charge. We offer small dishes like cheeses, smoked meats, and seasonal bites to complement your flight.
-
Yes, we are open on most holidays. However, it’s always a good idea to check our website for special holiday hours.
-
We rotate our flights regularly to highlight new, seasonal, or rare whiskeys — so there’s always something new to explore on return visits.